Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | Vaseline Lip Therapy | |
|---|---|---|
| Primary ingredient | Organic coconut oil | White petrolatum (petroleum jelly) |
| Delivers actual moisture | Yes — oils penetrate and hydrate | No — only prevents moisture loss |
| Petroleum-derived | No | Yes — 100% petroleum |
| Contains nutrients | Yes — vitamin E, fatty acids | No nutritional value |
| Absorbs into skin | Yes — lightweight absorption | No — sits on surface only |
| Organic certified | Yes | No |
| Shelf life approach | Vitamin E provides natural antioxidant preservation | Petroleum is inherently shelf-stable (inert material) |
| Packaging sustainability | Recyclable tube | Small plastic tub or squeeze tube — mixed recyclability |
| Where manufactured | Made in the USA | Manufactured globally by Unilever |
| Available varieties | Focused single formula — perfected simplicity | Multiple flavored varieties (rosy lips, cocoa butter, aloe, etc.) |
Primary ingredient
Organic coconut oil
White petrolatum (petroleum jelly)
Delivers actual moisture
Yes — oils penetrate and hydrate
No — only prevents moisture loss
Petroleum-derived
No
Yes — 100% petroleum
Contains nutrients
Yes — vitamin E, fatty acids
No nutritional value
Absorbs into skin
Yes — lightweight absorption
No — sits on surface only
Organic certified
Yes
No
Shelf life approach
Vitamin E provides natural antioxidant preservation
Petroleum is inherently shelf-stable (inert material)
Packaging sustainability
Recyclable tube
Small plastic tub or squeeze tube — mixed recyclability
Where manufactured
Made in the USA
Manufactured globally by Unilever
Available varieties
Focused single formula — perfected simplicity
Multiple flavored varieties (rosy lips, cocoa butter, aloe, etc.)
Who Owns Vaseline Lip Therapy?
Big Corp SubsidiaryUnilever(UL) -- Consumer Goods
Also makes: Dove, Axe, Hellmann's, Ben & Jerry's, Knorr
Why Numbrrrz Wins
Plant-based organic oils instead of petroleum jelly
Actively moisturizes rather than just creating an occlusive barrier
Contains vitamin E and jojoba oil for actual lip nutrition
No petroleum-derived ingredients at all
Organic and sustainably sourced ingredients
Lighter texture that absorbs rather than sitting on the surface

Deep Dive
Learn more about Vaseline Lip Therapy and the ingredients mentioned in this comparison.
Why Switch to Numbrrrz?
Vaseline Lip Therapy is essentially petroleum jelly for your lips. While petroleum jelly is an effective occlusive barrier — meaning it prevents moisture loss — it delivers zero actual moisture or nutrients to lip tissue. It sits on the surface of your lips like a plastic wrap, which can feel moisturizing but does nothing to repair or nourish dry, damaged skin. If your lips are already well-hydrated, Vaseline can help them stay that way. But if your lips are dry, it just locks in the dryness. Numbrrrz takes the opposite approach: our organic coconut and jojoba oils actively deliver moisture and nutrients INTO lip tissue, and then beeswax seals it in. Petrolatum — the sole active ingredient in Vaseline Lip Therapy — is a semi-solid mixture of hydrocarbons derived from petroleum refining. It contains no vitamins, no essential fatty acids, no antioxidants, and no compounds that interact beneficially with skin biology. Its only function is physical: it forms an inert, water-resistant film that reduces transepidermal water loss. Compare that with organic coconut oil, which is rich in lauric acid (antimicrobial), medium-chain fatty acids (easily absorbed for deep hydration), and natural vitamin E. Or organic jojoba oil, whose molecular structure is so similar to human sebum that skin absorbs it readily as if it were its own natural oil. Numbrrrz ingredients do not just sit there — they actively participate in lip health. There is a reason Vaseline has been around for over 150 years — petroleum jelly genuinely works as a barrier, and for wound care or extreme-weather protection, that occlusivity has real value. We are not saying Vaseline is dangerous. We are saying it is incomplete. For daily lip care, you want a product that moisturizes AND protects. Numbrrrz gives you both in one application, so you are building lip health every time you use it rather than just temporarily sealing whatever moisture happens to be there.
Get Your Free Ingredient Safety Report
Enter your email and we'll send you a personalized breakdown of the most common harmful ingredients in your daily products.
