Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature |  Numbrrrz | Fresh Sugar Lip Treatment |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $36 for 3-pack | ~$26 for 1 tube |
| Ingredient count | 4 | 20+ |
| Contains sugar | No | Yes |
| Contains silicones | No | Yes (dimethicone) |
| Organic ingredients | Yes | No organic certification |
| Purpose | Pure lip care and hydration | Tinted lip treatment / cosmetic |
| Preservative approach | Vitamin E — natural antioxidant | Synthetic preservatives including phenoxyethanol |
| Packaging value | 3 tubes for $36 — focused on product, not presentation | Premium single tube for $26+ — luxury packaging and retail markup |
| Ingredient transparency | 4 ingredients you can pronounce | 20+ ingredients including complex chemical names |
Price
$36 for 3-pack
~$26 for 1 tube
Ingredient count
4
20+
Contains sugar
No
Yes
Contains silicones
No
Yes (dimethicone)
Organic ingredients
Yes
No organic certification
Purpose
Pure lip care and hydration
Tinted lip treatment / cosmetic
Preservative approach
Vitamin E — natural antioxidant
Synthetic preservatives including phenoxyethanol
Packaging value
3 tubes for $36 — focused on product, not presentation
Premium single tube for $26+ — luxury packaging and retail markup
Ingredient transparency
4 ingredients you can pronounce
20+ ingredients including complex chemical names
Why Numbrrrz Wins
Dramatically lower price — Numbrrrz is a fraction of Fresh's $26+ per tube
No sugar (can actually encourage lip licking and drying)
4 clean ingredients vs. Fresh's 20+ ingredient formula
No synthetic dyes or tints
No dimethicone or silicones
Organic certification vs. Fresh's conventional luxury formula
Deep Dive
Learn more about Fresh Sugar Lip Treatment and the ingredients mentioned in this comparison.
Why Switch to Numbrrrz?
Fresh Sugar Lip Treatment is a luxury product priced at $26+ per tube, positioned more as a tinted lip cosmetic than a serious lip care product. While it contains some beneficial oils, it also includes sugar (which can dry lips by encouraging licking), dimethicone (silicone), synthetic dyes, and 20+ total ingredients. For genuine lip care — not cosmetic tinting — Numbrrrz provides superior hydration with organic ingredients at roughly one-sixth the price. The ingredient list of Fresh Sugar Lip Treatment reveals a product caught between skincare and cosmetics. It contains dimethicone and dimethicone crosspolymer (silicones that create a smooth slip on application), sugar (sucrose, which is the brand's signature ingredient but serves no dermatological purpose on lips and actively encourages licking), phenoxyethanol (a synthetic preservative), various tinting dyes for the colored versions, and a long tail of processing agents and stabilizers. The oils present — including meadowfoam seed oil and grapeseed oil — are genuinely good for skin but appear well below silicones and sugar in the ingredient list, meaning they are present in smaller concentrations. Numbrrrz puts the nourishing ingredients first and only: organic coconut oil, organic jojoba oil, beeswax, and vitamin E. No filler, no cosmetic trickery. Fresh has built a beautiful brand that makes applying lip product feel like a luxury ritual, and there is real value in that experience. If you want a tinted lip product that makes you feel pampered, Fresh fills that niche. But if your primary goal is lip health — keeping your lips moisturized, nourished, and protected throughout the day — you are paying a steep premium for packaging, brand cachet, and Sephora shelf placement. Numbrrrz does the actual lip care job better, with cleaner ingredients, at a fraction of the cost. Use Numbrrrz for lip health and save Fresh for when you want a cosmetic treat.
Get Your Free Ingredient Safety Report
Enter your email and we'll send you a personalized breakdown of the most common harmful ingredients in your daily products.
