Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature |  Numbrrrz | Carmex |
|---|---|---|
| Contains menthol | No | Yes |
| Contains camphor | No | Yes |
| Contains phenol | No | Yes |
| Contains salicylic acid | No | Yes |
| Petroleum-based | No — organic oils + beeswax | Yes — petrolatum base |
| Creates dependency cycle | No | Yes — irritants cause reapplication need |
| Preservative approach | Vitamin E (nourishing antioxidant) | Phenol doubles as preservative and active irritant |
| Suitable for sensitive lips | Yes — no known irritants | No — multiple irritants can trigger reactions |
| Ingredient transparency | 4 simple, recognizable ingredients | Mix of active drug ingredients and inactive petroleum compounds |
Contains menthol
No
Yes
Contains camphor
No
Yes
Contains phenol
No
Yes
Contains salicylic acid
No
Yes
Petroleum-based
No — organic oils + beeswax
Yes — petrolatum base
Creates dependency cycle
No
Yes — irritants cause reapplication need
Preservative approach
Vitamin E (nourishing antioxidant)
Phenol doubles as preservative and active irritant
Suitable for sensitive lips
Yes — no known irritants
No — multiple irritants can trigger reactions
Ingredient transparency
4 simple, recognizable ingredients
Mix of active drug ingredients and inactive petroleum compounds
Who Owns Carmex?
IndependentCarma Laboratories -- Lip Care
Why Numbrrrz Wins
No menthol, camphor, or phenol — zero dependency-creating irritants
No petrolatum or petroleum-derived ingredients
No salicylic acid (a chemical exfoliant harsh on lips)
No artificial flavors or fragrances
Will not create lip balm addiction cycle
Genuinely heals and moisturizes instead of just numbing and irritating
Deep Dive
Learn more about Carmex and the ingredients mentioned in this comparison.
Why Switch to Numbrrrz?
Carmex is perhaps the worst offender in creating lip balm dependency. Its formula contains menthol, camphor, phenol, AND salicylic acid — a cocktail of irritants that feel soothing initially but actively damage and dry out lip tissue, forcing you to reapply constantly. This is not an accident; it is a business model built on dependency. The petroleum base does not deliver any actual moisture. Switching to Numbrrrz breaks this cycle entirely. Our four organic ingredients heal and nourish without any irritants, so your lips actually get better over time instead of worse. Here is what each of those Carmex ingredients actually does to your lips. Camphor is classified by the FDA as a counterirritant — it literally works by irritating tissue to create a sensation that distracts from the original discomfort. Menthol operates similarly, triggering cold-sensitive nerve receptors to create a cooling feeling while mildly irritating the skin. Phenol is a chemical compound that can cause chemical burns at high concentrations and acts as a mild anesthetic at the levels found in Carmex, numbing your lips rather than healing them. Salicylic acid is a beta hydroxy acid that chemically exfoliates skin — useful for acne treatment, but aggressive on the thin, delicate tissue of your lips. Together, these four ingredients create a cycle: irritate, numb, exfoliate, dry out, repeat. Numbrrrz contains zero irritants. Organic coconut oil moisturizes, organic jojoba oil conditions, beeswax protects, and vitamin E repairs. We will acknowledge that Carmex has a dedicated following, and the tingling sensation genuinely feels like it is doing something. For people with occasional cold sores, the medicinal properties may provide temporary symptom relief. But for everyday lip care — which is what most Carmex users are actually reaching for — you want ingredients that build lip health over time, not ingredients that create an endless need for reapplication. The first week after switching from Carmex to Numbrrrz can feel like withdrawal, but by day seven, most people report the healthiest lips they have had in years.
Get Your Free Ingredient Safety Report
Enter your email and we'll send you a personalized breakdown of the most common harmful ingredients in your daily products.
